Controversial Renovation of Greenpoint’s Historic Church into Luxury Condos

The transformation of a cherished community landmark in Greenpoint into a luxury condominium has sparked outrage among locals. Once boasting a stunning facade with stained-glass windows and ornate brickwork, the building—originally the Park Church Co-op—has been dramatically altered, prompting accusations of disrespect and aesthetic vandalism.

Last week, construction barriers were removed, revealing a gutted structure. The iconic stained-glass arch was removed, and the elaborate stairway torn down. The building’s face was painted a plain, muted white, replacing its former grandeur. Critics, including historic restoration specialist Michael Malhas, expressed deep frustration, criticizing the reckless loss of original features and the off-center window above the entrance, which replaces a revered stained-glass masterpiece.

Many community members believe the overhaul signifies gentrification’s encroachment, transforming a beautiful, historically significant space into what some describe as a cheap, cookie-cutter development devoid of character. A mocked-up version of the final project previously displayed elements of the original design, such as red brick and stained glass, but the current realization diverges sharply from that vision.

Neighbors who once relied on the church for community programs now see it replaced with a cold, commercial structure. Long-time resident Matt Basso lamented, “It was so pretty before; now it’s just ugly.” The community’s efforts to preserve the church through crowdfunding failed to compete with the deep pockets of developers who prioritized profit over preservation.

Additionally, critics argue that this development reflects broader trends of gentrification, where affordable housing is replaced by opulent residences for the wealthy. Some residents also feel uncomfortable living in a former religious space, adding to the controversy.

Developers claim they aimed to retain the building’s historic character, stating that they preserved as much of the structure as possible. The project is expected to be completed by the end of summer, pending final exterior and interior updates.