Engagement Rumors Circulate as Caitlin O’Connor Displays Diamond Ring in Italy

During a recent trip to Italy, Caitlin O’Connor was seen wearing a diamond ring on her left hand, sparking speculation of an engagement with her boyfriend, Joe Manganiello.

Photos show the TV host enjoying a dinner at the luxury Le Naumachie restaurant in Taormina, smiling brightly and showcasing the ring. Following their meal, the couple took a leisurely walk near a ceramics shop and then headed back to the San Domenico Palace Hotel.

O’Connor styled a colorful, patterned short-sleeve dress paired with wedge sandals, while Manganiello wore a black-and-white patterned short-sleeve button-up shirt with black pants. At one point, she rested her arm on his shoulder as they strolled together.

The 48-year-old actor, known for his role in “Magic Mike,” and 34-year-old O’Connor reportedly started dating shortly after Manganiello’s separation from Sofia Vergara in July 2023, ending a seven-year marriage. It is believed that they moved in together last February, though sources indicated O’Connor still maintained her own residence.

The couple made their relationship official on social media when Manganiello shared a Valentine’s Day post featuring O’Connor. Sources have described their bond as passionate, with a shared connection rooted in their Pittsburgh origins and love of travel. Recently, reports surfaced that they took their relationship to a new level by moving in together.

Both have expressed happiness about their relationship, with insiders describing them as “super, super happy” and very affectionate as they continue building their life together.