City Pet Shops Face Ban on Selling Birds Under New Legislation

A proposed bill in the New York City Council aims to prohibit pet stores from selling birds such as parrots, finches, cockatiels, and macaws, sparking controversy among animal advocates and local retailers.

Supporters argue that the ban is essential to prevent inhumane breeding practices and reduce overcrowded, barren cages that cause suffering among captive birds. Advocates highlight that these animals are sentient beings deserving of proper care, not mere commodities or decorations.

However, bird sellers contend the legislation threatens their livelihoods, with many warning that it could force numerous small businesses out of operation. “They’re going to force people out of business,” said Sayari Hichem, owner of Royal Birds & Supplies in Queens, who also functions as a rescue and sanctuary for birds. He fears the bill’s broad restrictions will push sales underground into illegal markets.

While the bill exempts poultry like chickens, it marks the first retail ban on live birds in the state. Animal welfare groups emphasize the cruelty of large-scale bird breeding operations, where birds often suffer from poor conditions, screeching or mutilating themselves in confinement.

Critics also warn about unintended consequences, such as the rise of unregulated breeding and black markets. Some, like Megan Walton of Pigeons for Miles, caution that without safeguards, the legislation could lead to a surge in backyard breeding operations, creating chaos similar to the past issues seen with wild animal restrictions.

Despite opposition, supporters argue that modern laws can transform the pet industry, emphasizing opportunities for humane alternatives. As the debate continues, advocates stress the importance of evolving standards to better protect animals and foster responsible pet ownership.