The Best NBA Second Options in 2025

While star talent often grabs headlines, team chemistry and role understanding are equally vital to success. A strong five-man lineup that complements each other’s strengths can be the difference between a playoff exit and a title run. Recent finalists like the Thunder, Knicks, and Timberwolves all showcased cohesive rotations, emphasizing the importance of well-balanced supporting casts.

No. 1: Jalen Williams, Oklahoma City Thunder

Arguably the most debated choice, Williams boasts qualities—advanced metrics, All-Defensive Second Team honors, and a resilient playoff performance—that set him apart from more established stars. Despite LeBron James’ superior traditional stats, Williams excelled in areas like plus-minus and defensive versatility, defending all five positions effectively. His impact was evident during the playoffs, helping OKC reach the Finals while often overshadowing a seasoned LeBron as a complementary star.

Overall, Williams demonstrates the type of versatile, impactful co-star that teams need—less overlap with the primary ball-handler, more contributions across offense and defense. His style of play makes him a superior fit as a second option to Shai Gilgeous-Alexander than LeBron James is to Luka Dončić, especially when considering age, health, and role specialization.

No. 2: LeBron James, Los Angeles Lakers

The legendary James remains one of the NBA’s top players at 40, continuing to perform at a high level despite recent setbacks like sciatica. His career longevity and sustained excellence are unmatched, but questions persist about his fit alongside Dallas star Luka Dončić. Defensive concerns have also arisen, with the Lakers’ defensive metrics suffering when James and Dončić play together.

James has largely embraced a secondary role this season, marking a significant shift for someone used to being the primary option. His ability to elevate his game at any age makes him a formidable second option—if health and fit cooperate.

No. 3: Evan Mobley, Cleveland Cavaliers

Mobley stands out as a two-way sensation, combining offensive versatility with elite defense—making All-NBA and All-Defensive teams and earning Defensive Player of the Year honors. His skill set resembles a younger Kevin Garnett, as he can defend all five positions while contributing offensively from the perimeter, post, or in transition. His development could determine Cleveland’s championship potential, making him a top-tier second option.

No. 4: Jimmy Butler, Golden State Warriors

Last year, Butler was Miami’s primary scorer, leading them to NBA Finals appearances and showcasing his ability to carry a team. His move to Golden State saw him thrive as a complementary star, providing defensive intensity, turnovers forced, and scoring efficiency. Butler’s relentless style and versatility make him an ideal second option for a star-studded team, capable of adapting to different roles depending on team needs.

No. 5: Karl-Anthony Towns, New York Knicks

Towns has transformed from a regular-season scorer to a winning contributor, helping the Timberwolves reach deep playoffs before being traded to the Knicks. His impact on the court is significant, with improved defense and consistent scoring—traits essential for a second option in a championship pursuit. His offensive skill set and size make him a valuable fit alongside Jalen Brunson on a team aiming for an East title.